Skip to content

Attack encyclopedia

Industroyer (CrashOverride) - the first malware designed to attack power grids

Industroyer (CrashOverride) - analysis of the December 2016 attack on the Ukrainian power grid: MITRE ATT&CK S0604 techniques, IEC 104/61850/OPC DA modules, the Sandworm group and lessons for the energy sector.

Józef SulwińskiJózef Sulwiński

Published 9 min read

IndustroyerCrashOverrideS0604SandwormICSSCADAOT securityMITRE ATT&CKenergy sector
Industroyer (CrashOverride) - the first malware designed to attack power grids
Contents
  1. Context - Ukraine as a cyber testing ground
  2. Anatomy of the attack - December 17, 2016
  3. Malware architecture - four protocols, one goal
  4. MITRE ATT&CK - technique mapping (S0604)
  5. Sandworm - who is behind Industroyer
  6. Industroyer2 - return in 2022
  7. Lessons for the energy sector
  8. Summary
  9. Sources

Kyiv, December 17, 2016, a few minutes before midnight. Outside temperatures drop below minus ten degrees Celsius. Millions of people sleep in their apartments when suddenly - without warning, without a storm, without any visible cause - the lights go out. One fifth of the Ukrainian capital loses power. In the control room of the “Pivnichna” (Northern) electrical substation operated by Ukrenergo, operators watch helplessly as SCADA screens stop responding to commands. Circuit breakers open and close in sequences that nobody ordered. The 330 kV substation serving northern Kyiv disconnects from the grid.

This was not an ordinary blackout. This was Industroyer - the first malware in history designed specifically to attack power grids.

Context - Ukraine as a cyber testing ground

To understand the significance of Industroyer, we need to go back one year. On December 23, 2015, hackers from the Sandworm group carried out the first documented cyberattack on energy infrastructure - striking three Ukrainian power distribution companies in the Ivano-Frankivsk, Kyiv and Cherkasy regions. They used BlackEnergy malware to gain access, while the actual power outage was executed manually - the attackers’ operators hijacked VNC sessions and clicked through SCADA interfaces, opening breakers one by one. 230,000 people lost power for several hours.

But the 2015 attack had a fundamental weakness - it required a human behind the keyboard. Each breaker had to be opened manually. This limited both scale and speed.

Industroyer eliminated that problem. It was fully automated.

Anatomy of the attack - December 17, 2016

The chronology of events reconstructed by researchers from ESET, Dragos and CERT-UA is as follows:

Phase 1 - Infiltration (summer-autumn 2016) Sandworm gained access to Ukrenergo’s corporate network, likely through spear-phishing. Over several months, they moved laterally, mapping the IT and OT network architecture, identifying hosts with access to control systems.

Phase 2 - Preparation (November-December 2016) The attackers installed a backdoor on workstations in the OT network. Industroyer was configured with precise IP addresses and ports of devices at the “Pivnichna” substation - meaning the attackers knew exactly which devices they were targeting.

Phase 3 - Strike (December 17, 2016, approx. 23:00 UTC+2) At the designated time, Industroyer automatically launched its payload modules. Each module communicated with substation devices using native industrial protocols - sending commands to open circuit breakers. The SCADA system lost control of the substation.

Phase 4 - Covering tracks After the main attack, a wiper module launched, overwriting system files and deleting event logs. Additionally, a DoS module attacked SIPROTEC safety devices - Siemens protection relays - attempting to prevent safe restoration of power.

The power outage lasted approximately one hour. Ukrenergo operators restored supply manually - by switching to local control mode. But researchers at Dragos Security established something alarming: the real objective of the attack was not a brief power outage. The attackers attempted to cause physical damage to the substation - so that re-energizing the grid would trigger overloads and permanent destruction of transformers.

Malware architecture - four protocols, one goal

Industroyer was distinguished by its modular architecture. Its main component (backdoor) communicated with the C2 server through the Tor network, ensuring anonymity for the operators. The critical elements, however, were four payload modules - each designed to communicate with ICS devices using a different industrial protocol:

IEC 60870-5-104 module

IEC 104 is one of the most widely used communication standards in European power grids - it is used to transmit telecommands between dispatch centers and substations. The Industroyer module acted as a rogue SCADA client - connecting directly to RTUs (Remote Terminal Units) and sending valid commands to open breakers. From the end device’s perspective, these commands were indistinguishable from legitimate operator commands.

IEC 60870-5-101 module

The serial version of the IEC 104 protocol, used in older installations. The module scanned COM ports on the infected workstation and sent control commands over RS-232/RS-485 serial links. This meant Industroyer could attack even devices not connected to an Ethernet network.

IEC 61850 module

IEC 61850 is a modern communication standard for electrical substations, based on the MMS (Manufacturing Message Specification) data model. The Industroyer module could discover devices on the substation network, read their configuration and send control commands to IEDs (Intelligent Electronic Devices).

OPC DA module

OPC Data Access is a classic communication interface between SCADA systems and field devices in Windows environments. The Industroyer OPC DA module scanned the network for OPC servers, enumerated their structure (groups, tags), and then modified values - changing breaker states.

This four-pronged architecture meant Industroyer could attack virtually any electrical substation in Europe - regardless of the protocol in use. It was a bespoke malware - a framework that could be configured for a specific target.

MITRE ATT&CK - technique mapping (S0604)

Industroyer is cataloged in the MITRE ATT&CK database as S0604. The key ICS techniques associated with this malware are listed below:

Technique ID Description in the context of Industroyer
Unauthorized Command Message T0855 Sending valid ICS commands (open/close breakers) without operator authorization
Manipulation of Control T0831 Changing the states of control devices in the electrical substation
Block Command Message T0803 Blocking legitimate operator commands - loss of control over the substation
Denial of Service T0814 DoS attack on SIPROTEC relays, disabling protective functions
Remote System Discovery T0846 Scanning the OT network to identify RTUs, IEDs and OPC servers
Standard Application Layer Protocol T0869 Using native ICS protocols (IEC 104, IEC 61850, OPC DA)
Data Destruction T0809 Wiper module deleting data and logs after the attack
Masquerading T0849 Backdoor disguised as a legitimate Windows system service
Automated Collection T0802 Automatic gathering of ICS device configuration information

The full list of techniques, mapped to tactics (Initial Access, Execution, Discovery, Collection, Inhibit Response Function, Impair Process Control, Impact), is available on the MITRE ATT&CK S0604 page.

More about the MITRE ATT&CK framework and its application in OT threat analysis - in our MITRE ATT&CK guide.

Sandworm - who is behind Industroyer

Industroyer is attributed to the Sandworm Team (also known as Voodoo Bear, IRIDIUM, Telebots, Unit 74455). This is a unit of Russia’s military intelligence service GRU (Main Intelligence Directorate of the General Staff), operating within the Main Centre for Special Technologies (GTsST).

In October 2020, the U.S. Department of Justice indicted six GRU officers from Unit 74455 for a series of cyberattacks, including:

  • The 2015 attack on the Ukrainian power grid (BlackEnergy)
  • The 2016 attack on the Ukrainian power grid (Industroyer)
  • The 2017 NotPetya attack ($10 billion in global damages)
  • The attack on the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang

Sandworm is one of the most active and destructive APT actors in the world. Their portfolio spans attacks on critical infrastructure, global-scale data destruction and disinformation operations.

Industroyer2 - return in 2022

On April 8, 2022 - six weeks after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine - Sandworm launched another attempt to attack the Ukrainian power grid. This time they used a variant named Industroyer2 (S1072 in the MITRE ATT&CK database).

Unlike the original, Industroyer2 was simplified - it contained only the IEC 60870-5-104 module, compiled as a single executable with hardcoded target IP addresses. The malware was scheduled to run on April 8 at 16:10 UTC via a Windows scheduled task.

This time the attack was stopped. CERT-UA in collaboration with ESET detected and neutralized the malware before it could execute its mission. In addition to Industroyer2, the attackers also deployed the wipers CaddyWiper, ORCSHRED, SOLOSHRED and AWFULSHRED - destroying data on Windows, Linux and Solaris systems.

The fact that Sandworm had an updated Industroyer source code six years after the original attack confirms the continuous development of this tool.

Lessons for the energy sector

Industroyer changed the threat landscape for energy infrastructure. Here are the key takeaways:

1. ICS protocols lack built-in authentication

IEC 104, IEC 61850 and OPC DA were designed in an era when OT networks were physically isolated. They do not provide sender authentication - any host that gains network access can send valid commands. This is not an implementation flaw - it is a protocol architecture feature.

TIP

Implement OT network segmentation with dedicated zones and conduits in accordance with IEC 62443. Monitor network traffic for anomalies - for example, control commands sent from hosts that do not normally communicate with RTUs.

2. Attack automation changes the scale of the threat

The shift from manual attack (BlackEnergy 2015) to a fully automated framework (Industroyer 2016) means the same attack can be repeated across dozens of substations simultaneously - without a proportional increase in the attacker’s operations team.

TIP

Deploy anomaly detection systems in OT networks (e.g. IDS dedicated to industrial protocols). Conduct regular incident response exercises that include scenarios involving loss of SCADA control.

3. Protection relays are a target in their own right

The DoS attack on SIPROTEC relays was not accidental. Disabling protection relays before power restoration could have caused physical damage to transformers - resulting in weeks or months of repairs instead of hours.

TIP

Ensure that protection relays are in a separate network segment with dedicated monitoring. Update firmware - Siemens released patches for the SIPROTEC vulnerabilities exploited by Industroyer.

4. Manual restoration procedures must exist

Ukrenergo operators restored power within an hour - because they were able to switch to local control and manually close breakers. In many modern substations, fully dependent on digital systems, this capability may not exist.

TIP

Regularly test manual restoration procedures. Make sure operators can operate the substation without the SCADA system.

Summary

Industroyer is a turning point in the history of industrial cybersecurity. It demonstrated that an automated attack on energy infrastructure is not a movie scenario - it is reality. Its modular architecture, support for four industrial protocols and association with a state actor (Sandworm/GRU) made it a benchmark case for ICS threat analysis.

Six years later, Industroyer2 confirmed that this tool is still under active development and ready for deployment. The only reason the 2022 attack failed was effective collaboration between CERT-UA and ESET - not a lack of attacker capability.

For organizations operating in the energy sector, the lesson is clear: protecting OT systems is not an optional add-on - it is a prerequisite for operational continuity.

Sources

  1. MITRE ATT&CK - Industroyer S0604
  2. MITRE ATT&CK - 2016 Ukraine Electric Power Attack C0025
  3. ESET - Win32/Industroyer: A new threat for industrial control systems (whitepaper)
  4. Dragos - CRASHOVERRIDE: Analyzing the Malware that Attacks Power Grids
  5. CISA - CrashOverride Malware Alert
  6. ESET - Industroyer2: Industroyer reloaded (2022)
  7. Wikipedia - 2016 Kyiv cyberattack
  8. Wikipedia - Industroyer

Need help in this area?

Our experts will help you assess the risk and plan next steps.

Talk to an expert

We'll discuss scope, methodology, and timeline.

Book a call